Nightmare vs waking the fallen

In my opinion, these two are the titans of avenged, the only albums to rival for the top spot on my list.

I feel like a lot of people feel that way, but still, let's talk about it. What do you vote for? Nightmare, or waking the fallen (for 2028's presidential elections)?

Here's how I would rate them (at the moment):

Intro: nightmare (ofc)

Lyrics: nightmare

Vocals: tied

Theme: nightmare

Guitar: tied

Drums: tied

Final track: nightmare (sorry all things will end, still love you)

Obviously it doesn't matter which you prefer, as long as you enjoy the music, I'm just curious about people's opinions.